Diplomacy for Ukraine is in full swing. Alongside the meeting between the leaders of China, the US and Russia, Xi Jinping, Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin, the so-called Coalition of the Willing also met in Berlin this Thursday (19.11.2026) to discuss ending Russia’s aggressive war and supporting Ukraine.
Just last week, Europeans agreed to create a negotiating team to represent the continent in potential future peace talks between Ukraine and Russia. The team consists of the so-called E5 countries: Germany, France, the United Kingdom, Italy and Poland, as well as representatives of the Council of the EU and the European Commission.
The agreement was reached after the two US negotiators signaled that Europe needed to be at the table for the next round of negotiations. At the talks held in Abu Dhabi early last week, delegations from the countries that have now been selected were present but not directly involved in the talks.
Kaja Kallas without a negotiating mandate
Ahead of the meeting, the EU High Representative for Foreign Policy, Kaja Kallas, who is often referred to as the EU’s chief diplomat, had expressed her readiness to take on the role of chief negotiator: “When it comes to European security, the treaties are very clear. Antonio Costa and the High Representative represent the EU on security issues.”
Antonio Costa is the president of the European Council, the body representing the 27 EU countries. Kallas added that the heads of state and government could now make a different decision. But when it was decided in 2024 who would take the top jobs in the European Union, it was clear that negotiations with Russia would take place over the next five years.
Kaja Kallas not quite ready for compromise?
According to the EU treaties, the High Representative conducts the Union’s common foreign and security policy. This includes representing the EU in these diplomatic areas and conducting dialogue with third parties.
Sabina Lange, a researcher at the Center for Diplomatic, Economic and Legal Studies at the University of Ljubljana, supports Kallas’ argument. According to her, member states would not violate the treaties, as there is a wide margin of action in foreign policy. However, such a decision would have political consequences.
Lange sees several reasons for the Europeans’ stance. They are related on the one hand to Kaja Kallas herself and on the other hand to the institution she represents. Kallas could be perceived as a “particularly strong negotiator” and not very willing to compromise, and for this reason could be rejected by the other side. The former Estonian prime minister was known as a harsh critic of Russia since the time of her appointment. The Estonian has also been criticized, especially by Germany, for her stance on Israel.
At the institutional level, its position may be weakened by the fact that it is tied to the mandate of member states and therefore does not have full autonomy in negotiations, says political scientist Lange.
Is the institution of the EU High Representative being weakened?
Paul Taylor, an associate researcher at the European Policy Centre (EPC), cites, in addition to personal reasons, the fact that member states do not want to give up their national sovereignty on such an important issue, which is about war and peace.
Taylor considers these developments a “serious blow” for both Kallas and the institution of the EU High Representative. In a statement to DW, the political analyst says that Kallas could somehow regain her position if she were to draft a genuine negotiating mandate together with the foreign ministers.
Asked about her unsuccessful attempt, Kallas stressed that she remains ready to take on the task. At the same time, she expressed relief that the issue has, at least for the moment, been clarified and that attention can now focus on the content of the negotiations. “There is enough work for everyone,” said the Estonian politician.
Will Russia accept the negotiating team?
Meanwhile, the Russian side is giving mixed signals about whether it will accept the negotiating team of at least seven members.
After meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping and US President Donald Trump, Kremlin leader Vladimir Putin said that European representatives could come to Moscow to present Europe’s position. It would then be decided in what format the talks with Ukraine would continue.
But from a European perspective, this issue is not yet completely closed. It is difficult to imagine that in the highest-level negotiations, seven chairs will be set aside for European representatives, alongside the presidents of the US, Russia and Ukraine.
The question of who would represent Europe in possible quadrilateral talks was dismissed as premature by German Chancellor Friedrich Merz last week in Dublin.

