Why do Russian billionaires dream of a Russia without Putin?

Since the start of the full-scale invasion of Ukraine on February 24, 2022, the relationship between Vladimir Putin and Russia’s wealthiest businessmen has been one of submission and silence. Just hours after the war began, the Russian president gathered more than 30 of the country’s billionaires in the Kremlin, urging them to support the government and work together to keep the economy afloat. None of them dared to react publicly.

By BBC

Russia’s wealthy elite are increasingly contemplating a future without Vladimir Putin, hoping to regain the political influence they lost under his rule. Amid the return of the oligarchy of the 90s, another authoritarian regime and the possibility of democracy, Russian billionaires are bracing for the changes that could follow the president’s departure.

Since the start of the full-scale invasion of Ukraine on February 24, 2022, the relationship between Vladimir Putin and Russia’s richest businessmen has been characterized by submission and silence. Just hours after the war began, the Russian president gathered more than 30 of the country’s billionaires in the Kremlin, urging them to support the government and work together to keep the economy afloat. None of them dared to react publicly. This silence has become a hallmark of Russia’s business elite, which over the years has learned that opposing the Kremlin can have serious consequences. The case of Mikhail Khodorkovsky, once the richest man in Russia, remains a warning to all who might consider challenging the president. After criticizing Putin and financing opposition groups, he ended up in prison for ten years on charges of tax evasion, fraud, and embezzlement, which he denied.

After the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, Russia experienced a period of extraordinary wealth for a small group of businessmen, known as oligarchs. During the 90s, the privatization of large state-owned enterprises enabled individuals with the right political connections to create enormous wealth and exert direct influence over decision-making. Corruption, political favoritism, and contract killings were part of the reality of the period.

But after Putin came to power in 2000, this elite was forced to give up political ambitions and accept the authority of the Kremlin. The president had no intention of sharing power with the billionaires and, while tightening his grip on institutions and the economy, he placed them in a position of dependence. Financier Bill Browder recalls how businessmen, who once behaved with arrogance and self-confidence in international forums, completely changed their behavior as soon as Putin appeared, turning into submissive people. However, the war in Ukraine and Western sanctions have increased discontent even among those who have remained loyal to the Kremlin. On the one hand, businessmen who opposed the war have risked losing their fortunes, while those who have supported the government have been rewarded with huge state contracts. Russia now has 155 billionaires, according to Forbes magazine, while their combined wealth has reached a record of nearly $700 billion. But this wealth no longer guarantees them the influence they once had.

Domestically, political decision-making has centered on Putin and his circle, while outside Russia, many of them have been isolated by sanctions, losing the ability to move freely, use private jets or anchor yachts in the most prestigious European ports. Analysts estimate that billionaires have begun to think about what will happen after the president leaves, as they realize that their current influence depends almost entirely on their relationship with him.

Although there is no sign of Putin’s imminent departure or any indication that he is facing health problems, his age and long tenure in power have led the Russian elite to contemplate a future without him. The president, who turned 74 last month, has led the country for nearly a quarter of a century. In the event of resignation or death while in office, according to the Constitution, he would be replaced by Prime Minister Mikhail Mishustin, who has so far shown no apparent presidential ambitions.

This could create a power vacuum and open the way for clashes between different interest groups. Analysts see three possible scenarios: the establishment of a more democratic system, the arrival of another authoritarian leader, or the return of oligarchs to the center of decision-making. However, the possibility of democracy is considered less credible, since during Putin’s rule democratic institutions have been significantly weakened and the country has become accustomed to political repression. One of the scenarios that seems to attract wealthy businessmen the most is the return of a system similar to that of the 90s, where a few powerful families and economic groups share political influence. According to analysts, the oligarchs would like a period when they could negotiate directly with the government, protect their assets and have an influence on government decisions.

Some have begun to build relationships with security officials and ministers, trying to position themselves for a possible political change. However, fears of Kremlin retaliation remain high. Those with significant cash wealth may have more room to play politically, while those who depend on state contracts and government favoritism have little room to maneuver, as they risk losing everything.

Another indicator of the changing atmosphere within the Russian elite is the way some businessmen have begun to refer to the president. According to Russian journalist and analyst Alexandra Prokopenko, in the past they used nicknames like “Nachalnik,” meaning boss, or “Perviy,” which translates to first, expressing a certain amount of respect for him. Now, some have started calling him “Ded,” meaning grandfather or old man, a term that she says also carries a dose of contempt. Prokopenko says that some businessmen are expressing a desire to return politics to public life, with less repression, more freedom of expression, and more open competition between parties. However, the fear is so great that even private conversations are conducted with extreme caution. She cites the case of an oligarch who sat on his phone throughout an interview, fearing that the secret services might eavesdrop on his communications.

Russian billionaire Andrey Melnichenko, one of the country’s richest men and known as the “fertilizer king” for his business interests in the fertilizer industry, has also attracted particular attention. Earlier this year, he gave an unusual interview to The Economist magazine, where, while echoing some of the Kremlin’s positions on the war in Ukraine and relations with the West, he called for a change in the way Russia is governed.

Melnichenko did not call for Putin’s removal, but argued that the country should move away from a model of power centered on one individual and engage more with the world. According to journalist Arkady Ostrovsky, who conducted the interview, the billionaire seemed to be seriously reflecting on Russia’s future and not simply repeating prepared political statements. Analysts believe his message may also have been a signal to other wealthy businessmen to start talking about the necessary changes. Despite growing discontent, the oligarchs are not expected to take direct steps against Putin as long as he is in power. They know that any attempt to challenge the president could cost them their freedom and wealth, while the current system of political control does not leave them much room for organization. American financier Mike Calvey estimates that it is easy for those living outside Russia to ask billionaires to stand up against the Kremlin, but the consequences for them would be imprisonment and the seizure of assets.

However, Putin’s departure will one day open a new chapter for Russia, and the oligarchs appear to be preparing to regain lost influence. The main question remains whether the president’s potential successors and the remaining regime structures will allow them to return to the center of power, or whether Russia will take a completely different direction.

Hot this week

Europe Beckons, but Corruption Keeps Pulling Ukraine Back

An article by Petra Kramer For more than a decade,...

Brussels, the New Vienna: Europe’s Headquarters is Infested with Espionage

An article by Yveta Cermakova and Edvard Vavra In the...

The best European countries to invest in property in 2025

According to a new study by 1st Move International,...

Power 25 for 2025: Who will impact EU policy this year?

As the new European Commission and Parliament sets off...

Five major economic hurdles Germany needs to overcome in 2025

Germany is set to face a tough 2025 with...

Related Articles